What To Do When Your Candidate Fails a Background Check

July 20, 2023
Background checks are essential for informed hiring decisions and maintaining a safe workplace. But what happens when a candidate fails a background check? In this blog post, we’ll explore the steps employers can take to navigate this situation.

What is a “failed” background check

A “failed” background check occurs when concerning information or alerts are discovered about a job candidate. However, it doesn’t automatically disqualify the candidate. The ultimate hiring decision should depend on the role and the specific information revealed.

Reasons to “fail” a background check

A failed background check can result from criminal history, employment or education record discrepancies, an unsafe driving record, or a failed drug test. Different checks provide different information, and evaluating the results is crucial for making an informed decision.

Things to consider about background checks

  1. Criminal history: Evaluate the severity of convictions and their relevance to the position.
  2. Employment history: Investigate any discrepancies between the resume and verification.
  3. Education history: Assess candidates with invalid or missing academic credentials.
  4. Motor vehicle record: Unsatisfactory driving records may exclude candidates from driving-related roles.
  5. Drug test: Failed drug tests can disqualify candidates based on the role and legal requirements.

What to do when a candidate “fails” a background check

  1. Consult your background check policy: Ensure consistency, compliance, and fair treatment of candidates.

  2. Send a pre-adverse action notice: Inform the candidate about adverse findings, provide the background check report, and outline their FCRA rights.

  3. Allow the candidate to respond: Give candidates the opportunity to dispute inaccuracies or provide additional context within the specified timeframe.

  4. Make a hiring decision: Consider your policy, individual assessments, and EEOC recommendations.

  5. Send a final adverse action notice: After the waiting period, communicate the decision, reasons, and dispute options.

Navigating Failed Background Checks: Guidelines and Solutions

Dealing with a failed background check is a challenge for employers. By following policies, complying with regulations, and considering individual circumstances, fair and informed hiring decisions can be made. Consult legal experts to ensure best practices in screening and hiring, ultimately fostering a secure and productive work environment.

If you’re in need of a reliable partner for background checks, Turn is here to simplify the process. With ongoing compliance and risk management in mind, Turn offers rechecks and continuous monitoring, keeping you updated on workers’ behavior and enhancing safety standards. 

Talk with our experts to uncover hidden inefficiencies and find faster, more effective ways to screen top talent.

Disclaimer: Turn’s Blog does not provide legal advice, guidance, or counsel. Companies should consult their own legal counsel to address their compliance responsibilities under the FCRA and applicable state and local laws. Turn explicitly disclaims any warranties or assumes responsibility for damages associated with or arising out of the provided information.

Download SOC 3 Report

Get a high-level overview of Turn’s security controls and compliance practices.

See How Turn Shields Resellers from FCRA Risk

Learn how our partner program simplifies compliance and reduces liability. Fill out the form to get the full guide.

Name

See How Turn Shields Resellers from FCRA Risk

Learn how our partner program simplifies compliance and reduces liability. Fill out the form to get the full guide.

Name
Partner Info - Step 1 of 5

Partner Info

Point of Contact Name
Email
Quotes and demos are for companies only (validation required). If you’re a candidate needing help, please use the chat in the bottom right corner. Thanks!
Business Address

Your Roadmap to Driver Retention

Get expert tactics for reducing churn, improving safety, and optimizing onboarding with real industry data and compliance tips.

Name

Stay Ahead of Staffing Risks

Discover how to tackle identity fraud, economic shifts, background check delays, and changing worker expectations with actionable, expert-backed strategies.

Name

Retailers Using AI See 2.5x Higher Profitability

Get the full breakdown on how AI improves job descriptions, reduces candidate drop-off, and speeds up hiring, all backed by industry stats.

Name

A Must-Read for Hospitality Hiring Teams

Learn how leading resorts, QSRs, and boutique hotels reduce screening friction, improve accuracy, and maintain trust across locations.

Name

A Must-Read for Gig Economy Hiring Teams

Discover how AI is helping gig economy marketplaces hire faster, smarter, and more efficiently than ever before.

Name

Enhance Patient Safety With Smarter Screening

Discover how continuous license checks, drug testing, and real-time alerts can prevent avoidable errors and boost care quality. See the 5 key tactics that work.

Name